Once more unto the breach! 2017 TBR Challenge

So in 2016 I managed exactly one TBR challenge post and one draft post that I never completed. Hopefully I can do better in 2017. And while I didn’t  manage to report on the TBR books that I read, I did at least read at least a book in my TBR pile each month before purchasing other books.

Some of the books in my TBR were books that I had started and put aside, thinking that some day I will finish this. In 2016 I actually restarted several of those books and realized that the day to refinish this story has not come and probably will never come. So those books became DNFs and now have been donated (or if ebooks deleted from my ebook reader). One things that I have gradually learned is that there are some books that don’t work for me and holding on to them in hopes that someday they might is just foolish. Who needs books (or anything else) that are simply clutter and dust catchers in your life?

Setting up this blog and planning to do this challenge did help (even though I failed miserably at the reporting part) because it did force to think about the many books that I had accumulated that have been sitting around unread (some for years!). I also purchased less books in 2016 because I was so aware that I did have all those books in the pile.

Wendy at The Misadventures of Super Librarian is once again organizing the TBR Challenge and she’s posted a new list of potential monthly themes. I’m not sure that I will follow exactly all the themes (for example, I don’t know if I have any true short shorts left in my TBR– ironically that was a category in my TBR that I read a lot of in 2016. But I’m going to look and see what is there). I also don’t know that every book will be a romance, I have other genres sitting on my TBR, some of which support the themes listed below and also need to be read.

But even if I don’t make the themes I’m going to try to keep to my resolution to read at least one book a month in my TBR before purchasing anything new. And I’m going to keep trying to be mindful about my 2017 book purchases.

So without further ado — here are the 2017 themes:

January 18 – We Love Short Shorts! (category romance, short stories, novella etc.)
February 15 – New-To-You Author
March 15 – Comfort Read (Favorite Author? Favorite Trope? Favorite Sub Genre?)
April 19 – Contemporary
May 17 – Something Different (outside your comfort zone, unusual setting, non-romance etc.)
June 21 – Favorite Trope (a favorite theme – amnesia? secret baby? fairy tale? friends-to-lovers? etc.)
July 19 – Series Catch-Up (a book from a series you’re behind on)
August 16 – Kicking It Old School (publication date 10 years or older)
September 20 – Historical
October 18 – Paranormal or Romantic Suspense
November 15 – Recommended Read (a book recommended to you by someone)
December 20 – Holiday Themes


TBR Challenge: Justice Calling by Annie Bellet*

This is the first book (novella) in the Twenty-Sided Sorceress Series. Annie Bellet describes this series as urban fantasy, but this opening book takes place in the small town of Wylde, Idaho — which backs onto a large national park. So urban is not the feeling I received from this novel despite the fact that Wylde boasts an antique store, the heroine’s comic and games store, and a college.

justice-calling-220x330Jade Crow, the heroine and the twenty-sided sorceress, has been on the run for years from her murderous ex-lover, Samir, a powerful sorcerer who wants to absorb her powers by devouring her heart. She’s chosen to settle in Wylde because it is a place of power where lots of other magical beings live and she hopes all those other types of magic will make it more difficult for Samir to sense her own.

But of course trouble happens and Jade is forced to decide whether she should help her friends or get the heck out of Wylde before Samir finds her hiding place.

Justice Calling follows many of the basic genre conventions of urban fantasy (and its older mystery cousins: hard-boiled and noir detective fiction). Like many urban fantasies (and detective stories) the story is narrated in the slightly snarky first-person voice of the protagonist, Jade Crow. And like many  other female-centered series in these genres (e.g., Kate Daniels or V. I. Warshawski), this first book opens with Crow trying to remain emotionally disengaged from those around her and ends with her choosing to become involved. And of course Crow’s loner status is because of her emotionally fraught past — which is partially revealed in the novella. Rejected by her birth family in her early adolescence (although it is not clear why in this novella) and scarred by the horrific deaths of her friends, who had become her second family, Crow’s backstory and emotional trajectory is familiar, not so much in its particulars but in the ways that it conforms to genre expectations.

It’s not that I didn’t enjoy reading this novella — it was a pleasant, competently written story, but many of the characters felt underdeveloped as did the setting. This made it hard for me to have much engagement with any of the characters and therefore reduced the emotional stakes of Crow’s final decision to stay and fight. As for the setting — I’ve noticed that in the urban fantasy and PI detective stories that I’ve read, the setting often plays a central role (e.g., Atlanta for Kate Daniels or Chicago for Warshawski). Here the setting felt generic and often I was confused about exactly what type of community Wylde was and what exactly was where.

There were some interesting ideas at play within this novella — I especially liked the fact that magic is like any other skill — you need to use it or you lose it. I think also the set up for the different kinds of magic shows promise.

I found this novella enjoyable but not enough so that I need to acquire the next one in the series and add it to my current skyscraper-high TBR pile. If I ever whittle my pile down to a reasonable height, I may decide to seek out the next book about Jade Crow and her friends.

*Yes I’m about one week late with this post and I rather suspect that this will be happening with all my TBR posts. But at least I’ve managed to get one book off the TBR pile and written the review!

2016 TBR Challenge

Wendy at The Misadventures of Super Librarian has been organizing a TBR Challenge the past few years. This year I’m going to try to participate. It seems to me a great way to help me go through the massive number of books that I keep accumulating and not reading.

One of my resolutions for this new year is no new books in a month unless I do the TBR challenge for that month and report on it. It doesn’t mean that I have to finish a book, but it does mean that I need to seriously go through my TBR pile and reduce it.

The challenges for this year are:

January 20 – We Love Short Shorts! (category romance, short stories, novella etc.)
February 17 – Series Catch-Up (a book from a series you are behind on)
March 16 – Recommended Read (a book that was recommended to you)
April 20 – Contemporary
May 18 – Something Different (outside your comfort zone, unusual setting, non-romance etc.)
June 15 – Favorite Trope (a favorite theme – amnesia? secret baby? fairy tale? friends-to-lovers? etc.)
July 20 – Award Nominee or Winner (links to past RITA finalists and winners TBA)
August 17 – Kicking It Old School (publication date 10 years or older)
September 21 – Random Pick (a built-in off-theme month – go where your mood takes you!)
October 19 – Paranormal or Romantic Suspense
November 16 – Historical
December 21 – Holiday Themes